Virtual medical visits get wary welcome from older adults, poll finds
The technology is there. The funding is nearly there. And the health providers are getting there.
But a new national poll suggests that people over 50 aren’t quite ready to fully embrace virtual health visits with their doctors and other providers — also known as telehealth.
Only 4 percent of those polled by the National Poll on Healthy Aging had had a video-based telehealth visit with a provider via smartphone or computer in the past year. Their reactions were mixed.
Additionally, more than 80 percent of older adults polled expressed at least one concern about seeing a doctor or other provider virtually rather than in person. And 47 percent worried about getting the technology to work.
But more than half said they’d be willing to try telehealth in some situations, for instance if they got sick while traveling or needed follow-up on previous care.
The poll, carried out by the U-M Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation with support from AARP and Michigan Medicine involved a national sample of more than 2,250 adults aged 50 to 80. They answered questions about many aspects of video-based telehealth.
Among the one-third of poll respondents whose health providers don’t yet offer telehealth, 48 percent said they’d be interested in trying it with their primary care provider. But fewer would try it for specialty or mental health care.
“As telehealth finally appears poised to live up to its potential, with insurance reimbursement in place or set to begin soon under many plans, and providers increasingly investing in systems, these poll data show a need to focus on the patient side,” said Jacob Kurlander, M.D., M.S., a U-M and VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System gastroenterology specialist and telehealth researcher who helped lead the poll.
“As the industry moves forward, we should heed the concerns and preferences of our patients, especially those over age 50, who use the most health care.”
Preeti Malani, M.D., the poll’s director and a professor of internal medicine at U-M, noted that focusing on certain types of telehealth visits might be a way to help older adults get comfortable with the concept and see its value.
“Telehealth won’t replace in-person medical examinations completely, but for situations where in-person visits aren’t essential, they can save time and resources for patients and providers alike,” she said. “Providers shouldn’t assume older adults aren’t receptive to virtual visits, but they should understand and work to overcome some of the reasons for hesitation.”
For instance, she pointed to the 64 percent of respondents who said they’d be interested in telehealth options if they became unexpectedly ill while traveling, and the 58 percent who said they’d be interested in using it for a return visit after seeing a provider in person for an issue.
But 71 percent were concerned that providers couldn’t do a physical exam over a webcam or smartphone camera, and 68 percent worried that the quality of care they’d receive wouldn’t be as good.
Indeed, among the small minority who had used telehealth, 58 percent said they felt that office visits offered better quality of care. Nearly half were concerned about privacy.
Low use, high potential
Telehealth as a concept has been around for decades, but has lagged in development until state and federal laws, and insurance plan coverages, aligned with the technical capability of health providers and consumer electronics. The poll was taken in spring of 2019, when many new policies and coverage provisions began to kick in.
Some of those changes will specifically affect older adults. Starting in 2020, Medicare Advantage HMO insurance plans will be able to reimburse health care providers for seeing patients via computer or smartphone. Veterans have increasing access to telehealth, as do people who receive their health coverage through their employer or Medicaid.
But providers that have begun to offer telehealth options may need to do a better job of letting their older patients know it’s an option, and helping them understand how it works, the poll suggests.
“Many older Americans can benefit from being able to get care through telehealth without long trips to their doctor’s office,” said Alison Bryant, Ph.D., senior vice president of research for AARP. “Telehealth allows people to schedule health-related appointments, request prescription refills, and link to health care providers when time or distance is a barrier. It can also support family caregivers who are taking care of their loved ones.”
What this means for providers and payors
Sameer Saini, M.D., M.S., who leads a Michigan Program on Value Enhancement (MPrOVE) Innovation Challenge project that partly supported the work, noted that further research is needed to understand the best uses of telehealth among older adult populations.
“Especially for patients with mobility and transportation issues, who live in rural areas, or who live far from specialty care providers, telehealth could be an important improvement in access,” said Saini, a U-M gastroenterologist and VA Center for Clinical Management Research acting director who is studying the use of telehealth in specialty care. “But we will need evidence-based approaches to sustain and increase participation.”
At CCMR, Saini directs the Program on Access, Community Care, and Specialty Care Services (ProACCeSS).
The National Poll on Healthy Aging results are based on responses from a nationally representative sample of 2,256 adults aged 50 to 80 who answered a wide range of questions online. Questions were written, and data interpreted and compiled by the IHPI team. Laptops and internet access were provided to poll respondents who did not already have them.
A full report of the findings and methodology is available at www.healthyagingpoll.org, along with past National Poll on Healthy Aging reports.